COG Round 106 Results: Grover Cleaves Competition

His election was delayed a few voting rounds but was never in doubt. As its 106th inductee, the Circle of Greats welcomes Grover Cleveland Alexander, the National League’s all-time pitching WAR leader. Alexander is also the career leader in the senior circuit in Wins (tied with Christy Mathewson) and Shutouts, and the modern era leader in Complete Games. In a career of twenty seasons, Alexander logged over 5000 IP and faced almost 21,000 batters, both second in the NL only to Warren Spahn in the modern era. More on Alexander after the jump.

Alexander hailed from Nebraska where his life on the family farm delayed his professional baseball career until age 22, a career he embarked upon only at the urging of locals with whom he played ball on weekends. One season in Class D and a second in Class B and Alexander was ready for the majors at age 24. Was he every ready!

Alexander took the NL by storm in 1911, logging 367 IP and posting a 28-13 record to become the last pitcher to lead his league in IP and Wins in a debut season. For good measure, he also led in CG, Shutouts, Batters Faced and H/9, and placed 2nd in Strikeouts and SO/9. Only his 3.2 BB/9 was less than stellar, limiting his ERA+ to “only” 133.

Addressing that one weakness, Alexander pushed his BB/9 steadily lower, reaching only 1.5 BB/9 in a breakthrough 1915 season in which he led in basically everything: IP, BF, Wins (with 31), W-L%, ERA, ERA+, FIP, CG, SHO, SO, SO/9, SO/BB, H/9 and WHIP (a career best 0.842). Alexander would lead in most of those same categories for the next two years, while recording 30 wins for three straight seasons to match Kid Nichols and Christy Mathewson for the longest such streak of seasons since 1893.

Alexanders first 7 seasons, each with more than 300 IP, produced totals of almost 2500 IP with 190 wins and 61 shutouts, all modern records to start a career. Despite an NL championship in 1915 and runner-up finishes the next two years, Philadelphia elected not to retain their ace after the 1917 season, fearing that he would be drafted into military service in France (as indeed he was). Instead, the Phillies sold Alexander to the Cubs for a very tidy sum, though the Cubs would have the last laugh, winning the 1918 pennant despite having Alexander miss almost the entire season.

Alexander survived the horrors of the front line but would bear the scars of that ordeal for the rest of his life. Loading a howitzer and pulling the lanyard left Alexander deaf in one ear and with a sore right pitching arm. But, those were minor complaints compared to the onset of severe epilepsy which Alexander tried to mask with drink (better to be thought a drunk than an epileptic, then still seen as a sign of demonic possession).

Returning to the Cubs in 1919, Alexander turned in two solid seasons including a career best 12 WAR campaign in 1920 in which he again led the NL in most statistical categories. But his age, afflictions and a sore arm resulted in plummeting strikeout totals starting in 1921. Those factors and the advent of the live ball era compelled Alexander to reinvent himself as a finesse pitcher for the back half of his career, a transformation he accomplished with apparent ease, totaling over 2000 IP with 35 WAR and 161 CGs aged 34+, the last  mark bettered only by Warren Spahn among live ball era pitchers.

Alexander’s life after baseball was little short of a living hell, one of the few bright spots coming with his election to the Hall of Fame in 1938. Alexander died in 1950, shortly after making his final public appearance at that year’s World Series.

My thanks, as always, to Baseball-Reference.com for statistical data and to Sabr.org for biographical details.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
brp
brp
9 years ago

As backward as a lot of the USA still is, it’s good to see we no longer consider epilepsy as caused by demonic possession. Glad we’re making some progress!

no statistician but
no statistician but
9 years ago

Re: Pete Alexander

Before we get too far along, I think it’s important to point out that Grover Cleveland Alexander is the best NL pitcher in history to this point whose career is entirely post 1893. He outpaces Mathewson by a stride or two, even though they won the same number of games and had remarkably similar stats in many respects. To me it is a sign of the weakness of the COG process that he waited even one round for admission, and another that this is just the second comment remarking on that admission. But, then, I don’t vote.

brp
brp
9 years ago

I think it’s (understandably) difficult for most people to have strong emotions about a player who last played 85 years ago. This is likely contributing to less discussion and less voting in general.

MikeD
MikeD
9 years ago
Reply to  brp

The competition and as you noted he pitched a long time ago. An easy selection, even if he wasn’t.

mosc
mosc
9 years ago

With all due respect to a fantastic deadball era pitcher, you’re stacking him directly against Eddie Collins, Greg Maddux, and Tom Seaver in your comments there and that’s stiff competition.

Havig
Havig
9 years ago
Reply to  mosc

Not to mention Walter Johnson & Ty Cobb as well.

There are maybe 40 players or so we could have put on a single ballot and said “All right, all or nothing! All of these guys in the COG on a single yes or no ballot otherwise we do them one at a time. To make this even tougher than the HOF they need to get yes on at least 90% of the ballots” and we would have cut about a years time off of this process.

But where is the fun in that?

no statistician but
no statistician but
9 years ago

mosc: JAWS ranks Alexander at 94.5, Seaver at 85.0, Mathewson at 84.1, Maddux at 81.6. I specified NL pitchers, by the way, and Seaver had three productive years in the AL. Further, Alexander leads the others in WAR by 9.5, 18.3, and 13.1 respectively; in ERA+ (tied with Mathewson), and WAA by 11.7, 21.2, and12.3 respectively. I’m no great fan of relying on such stats and rankings without additional evidence, but Alexander sweeps the field in every category, plus leading the NL in career wins(tied with M), shutouts, and complete games. Havig? Hartvig? Walter Johnson is an AL pitcher and… Read more »

Dave Humbert
Dave Humbert
9 years ago

nsb: The only reason Alexander had to wait a few rounds was because his birth year was heavily loaded with COG talent (just as 1931 was with Mantle/Mays/Mathews). Doug split 1887 into 2 parts, so Alexander faced Eddie Collins but not Walter Johnson or Shoeless Joe Jackson (all born 1887). Alexander came in 2nd (the voters selected Collins with 123.9 WAR instead of Alexander’s 117 WAR). Part 2 of 1887, Alexander came in second again, this time to Johnson’s 152.3 WAR. 1886 brought Ty Cobb with 151 WAR, again Alexander was second. He got in on his 4th try in… Read more »