COG 1914 Results: Joltin’ Joe Has Left and Gone … to the Circle

Joe DiMaggio did not appear on 56 consecutive ballots cast, but did enjoy overwhelming support, becoming the 71st inductee into the High Heat Stats Circle of Greats. More on the Yankee Clipper, and the voting, after the jump.

*********************************************
For his career, DiMaggio’s OPS in home games was .931, which is excellent. It puts him in the top 60 all-time for career OPS in home games, among hitters with at least 2,000 PAs at home since 1914. But his OPS in road games — wow!:

Highest Career On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS), In Road Games, Since 1914 (min. 2,000 road PAs)
1. Babe Ruth 1.148
2. Lou Gehrig 1.102
3. Ted Williams 1.082
4. Barry Bonds 1.037
5. Joe DiMaggio 1.015

How does Joe’s road/home OPS difference rank all-time? I created a spreadsheet of of home and road OPS numbers for the 505 hitters since 1914 who had both 3,000 or more careers PAs on the road and 3,000 or more career PAs at home. Here are the largest differences where the player’s road OPS was higher than home OPS, among those 505 hitters:

1. Brady Anderson (.830 road OPS) – (.743 home OPS) = .087
2. Mike Piazza (.960 road OPS) – (.860 home OPS) = .080
3. Adrian Gonzalez (.901 road OPS) – (.822 home OPS) = .079
4. Joe DiMaggio (1.015 road OPS) – (.938 home OPS) = .077
5. Willie Davis (.758 road OPS) – (.685 home OPS) = .073

In case you’re curious, the largest home OPS over road OPS gaps among this group of 505 guys are held by 1. Chuck Klein, 2. Bobby Doerr, 3. Hank Greenberg, 4. Dante Bichette and 5. Larry Walker.

*********************************************

Joe D. totaled 78.2 Wins Above Replacement for his career, according to Baseball-Reference, but did so having played in only 13 major league seasons from debut through retirement. To illustrate the uniqueness of that combination, let’s look at the fewest career seasons in the majors played, among the 89 retired non-pitchers who have accumulated at least 64 career WAR:
13 seasons, Joe DiMaggio
14 seasons, Arky Vaughan
15 seasons, Johnny Mize, Ron Santo and Jeff Bagwell
16 seasons, Ed Delahanty, Pee Wee Reese and Ryne Sandberg

Among pitchers who have accumulated at least 64 pitching WAR (baseball-reference version) since 1900, the shortest careers in terms of seasons have been the 14-season career of Stan Coveleski and the 16-season careers of Christy Mathewson, Roy Halladay and Carl Hubbell.

*********************************************

DiMaggio’s popular image for many years has been tied to some interesting memes. Proceeding backward in time, there was the rather patrician silver-haired gentleman selling what were at the time innovative coffee-makers; the seemingly prudish half of an odd couple with the world’s most famous sex symbol; the remote veteran warily eyeing the young Mickey Mantle as a rival; and the consummate professional batter with the enormously famous hitting streak. But one needs to remember that going way back to the early years of his career, Joe was simply a spectacular young ballplayer, the Mike Trout of his time, if you will.

Most Total Bases in A Season By a Hitter Age 23 or Younger, MLB History
1. Joe DiMaggio (1937, Age 22) 418
2. Hal Trotsky (1936, Age 23) 405
3. Albert Pujols (2003, Age 23) 394
4. Al Simmons (1925, Age 23) 392
5. Alex Rodriguez (1998, Age 22) 384

Most Runs Created, Age 21 Through 26, MLB History
1. Jimmie Foxx 950
2. Albert Pujols 907
3. Mickey Mantle 869
4. Joe DiMaggio 857
5. Alex Rodriguez 806

**********************************************

Over the 56 games of The Streak in 1941, DiMaggio scored 56 runs, had 55 RBI and his OPS was 1.181. After going hitless on July 17 to end the record-breaking streak, he ran off another 16-game hit streak running from July 18 through August 2, during which his OPS was 1.345.

**********************************************

Notes on this round’s voting:

–Roy Campanella has been sitting “on the bubble”, vulnerable to falling off the ballot at any time, since his initial birth year ballot in Round 62.  He nearly reached the 25% support level needed to get off the bubble in the last round. This round he broke through that level.  So Campy will be safe from falling off the ballot for at least one round.

–After sitting more or less with the rest of the pack of holdovers for most of this round, Joe Gordon appeared on both of the final two ballots cast, sneaking up to a showing of exactly 25% of the vote, just enough to move him from two to three assured rounds of eligibility.

–Otherwise, this was stable ballot from a holdover status point of view. Despite DiMaggio vacuuming up many votes, all the holdovers managed to stay above the 10% threshold, meaning all the guys on the bubble survive and the holdovers with accumulated ballot survival rights continue to hang on to them.

–It’s been a while since we’ve had any bubble guy drop off the eligible list. In the Round 66 voting, Ralph Kiner fell below the 10% threshold and teetered off the eligible list, after Hoyt Wilhelm had been hit with a similar outcome in the Round 65 voting. Since then, the bubble guys have been hanging on. However, with three redemption round beneficiaries about to re-join the eligible list the fight for eligibility survival may now get tougher.

************************************************
The full spreadsheet showing this round’s vote tally is here: COG 1914 Vote Tally.

The vote summary for recent Circle of Greats voting rounds is here: COG Vote Summary 2 .  An archive with details of the 1968 through 1939 rounds is here: COG 1968-1939 Vote Summary .  In both cases, raw vote totals for each past round appear on Sheet 1 and the percentage totals for each past round appear on Sheet 2.

************************************************
A spreadsheet listing the full membership to date of the Circle of Greats, along with some of their stats, is here: Circle of Greats Membership . You can also find that same link any time by clicking on “Circle of Greats” at the top of the High Heats Stats home page.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dr. Doom
Dr. Doom
10 years ago

Here’s your weekly update on the all-time vote-getters leaderboard, as well as my thoughts on the round. Aren’t you lucky? I know you’ve been DYING to read this. As always, “active” players on the ballot marked with a *. Here we go: *Craig Biggio – 738 John Smoltz – 658 Kenny Lofton – 608 Ryne Sandberg – 607 *Roberto Alomar – 547 *Eddie Murray – 523 Edgar Martinez – 507 Lou Whitaker – 493 Bobby Grich – 376 Sandy Koufax – 375 Tony Gwynn – 346 Willie McCovey – 336 *Whitey Ford – 284 Juan Marichal – 268 Tom Glavine… Read more »

Dr. Doom
Dr. Doom
10 years ago
Reply to  birtelcom

I would be ready for a third one. I don’t know that it’s horribly necessary to keep it all in one document, especially if you keep the “relevant” players in the most up-to-date version. But that’s just me; others may feel different about that.

Voomo Zanzibar
Voomo Zanzibar
10 years ago

64 WAR in 13 seasons – only Dimaggio

Close, but not on the list is Lou Boudreau.
63 WAR in 15 seasons.
But, his first season had 2 PA.
His last season had 3 PA.

So, really, 63.1 WAR in 13 seasons.

JasonZ
10 years ago

Outstanding summary. As always. Sometime on May 28, 1933, the 19-year-old son of an immigrant fisherman got a hit in a Pacific Coast League game. He got a hit in a game on July 25, 1933 too. He got at least one hit in the other 59 games he played between those two too. Incomprehensible that the same man could author two such lengthy streaks in the course of his professional career. 81 years after the 61 game hit streak, the very same man would dominate an online vote, in a way that confirms he is one of the very… Read more »

paget
paget
10 years ago
Reply to  JasonZ

JasonZ, Nice. One thing that I’d add though. If I can borrow a quip from Albert Einstein, the truly incomprehensible thing about DiMaggio authoring two such streaks is that it actually *is* comprehensible. My sense is that sabr-folk tend to dismiss the relevance/significance of DiMaggio’s ’41 hit streak without really taking into consideration what the streak reveals about his -in some ways at least, unparalleled- greatness as a ball player. If one were to design a player who would be most *likely* to hit safely in 56 games in a row, what kind of player would you want: 1)Someone who… Read more »

paget
paget
10 years ago

Birtelcom, I’m glad to see that you put some emphasis on the significance of DiMaggio’s Home/Road splits. I’ve made this point before here, but it’s worth repeating that WAR seriously underestimates the value of players whose stats are damaged by playing their home games in parks that hurt them. I realize that WAR attempts to understand player-value with H/R splits in mind; the problem, though, (at least as I understand the process) is that WAR looks only at the overall run-scoring environment of a ball park without taking into consideration the peculiarities of offense within that ball park. By which… Read more »

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago
Reply to  paget

DiMaggio has the greatest home/road discrepancy in HR. His 148 HR at home and his 213 HR on the road give him 65 more on the road.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

I should have mentioned greatest discrepancy with more HR on the road. Mel Ott has 135 more HR at home than on the road.