Tempered ambition: masters of the sacrifice

Zack CozartHHS reader Jacob identified that Zack Cozart is currently leading the NL in both sacrifice hits (i.e. sacrifice bunts) and sacrifice flies. Should Cozart still have the same standing at the end of the season, he would become the first player since the sac fly was first officially recorded in 1954 to lead his league in both categories in the same season. Not only that, he would become just the fifth player to lead in both categories at any point in a career.

More on sacrifice hitting after the jump.

First, let’s look at sacrifice bunts. These have been recorded in the AL since its inception in 1901, and in the NL since 1894, the year after the pitching rubber was moved to its current distance of 60 feet 6 inches from home plate.

Sacrifice Hits 1895-2012

Not surprisingly. the sac bunt had its heyday in the dead-ball era, emphasized by Ray Chapman‘s record total of 67 sac bunts while batting 2nd  for the 1917 Indians. With the advent of the live-ball era in 1920 and excepting a brief uptick in the run-starved wartime years, sac bunts declined steadily, even during the so-called second dead-ball era in the late 1960s. (Note that the numbers prior to the 1930s are somewhat inflated as, at various time, sacrifice hits included what we now call sacrifice flies, as well as fly outs that advanced a runner to any base.)

There was a brief uptick in both leagues with the advent of the 1970s running game, but the downward trend has continued since, more steeply in the AL reflecting a continuation of the league divergence resulting, not unexpectedly, from the introduction of the DH rule.

These are the players who have most often led their league in sacrifice hits.

Player AL NL Total
Mule Haas 6 6
Juan Pierre 1 3 4
Omar Vizquel 3 1 4
Otto Knabe  4 4
Phil Rizzuto 4 4
Bert Campaneris 3 3
Bucky Harris 3 3
Craig Reynolds 3 3
Marty Barrett 3 3
Ray Chapman 3 3

As mentioned above, sacrifice flies were, at various times, counted among sacrifice hits, but have been counted separately in both leagues since 1954. Here are those trends.

Sacrifice Flies 1954-2012

After declining through the 1950s and 1960s, there was a noticeable jump in the 1970s after which the trend is fairly constant until declining over the past decade. The league divergence in sacrifice hits resulting from the DH rule is also evident here, with significantly more sacrifice flies for AL teams.

These are the batters who have most often led their league in sacrifice flies.

Player

AL

NL

Total

Brooks Robinson 4 4
Johnny Bench 3 3
Ron Santo 3 3
Orlando Cabrera 3 3
Jackie Jensen 3 3

Clearly quite different types of hitters from the sacrifice hits leaders. To further illustrate this point, here are the players since 1954 with seasons recording double-digit totals for both sacrifice hits and sacrifice flies.

Rk Player Year SH SF Age Tm G PA R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG Pos
1 Juan Uribe 2005 11 10 25 CHW 146 540 58 121 23 3 16 71 34 77 .252 .301 .412 *6
2 Ricky Gutierrez 2001 17 11 31 CHC 147 606 76 153 23 3 10 66 40 56 .290 .345 .402 *6
3 Roberto Alomar 1999 12 13 31 CLE 159 694 138 182 40 3 24 120 99 96 .323 .422 .533 *4/D
4 Kevin Elster 1996 16 11 31 TEX 157 596 79 130 32 2 24 99 52 138 .252 .317 .462 *6
5 Omar Vizquel 1995 10 10 28 CLE 136 622 87 144 28 0 6 56 59 59 .266 .333 .351 *6
6 Jerry Browne 1990 12 11 24 CLE 140 610 92 137 26 5 6 50 72 46 .267 .353 .372 *4
7 Wally Joyner 1986 10 12 24 CAL 154 674 82 172 27 3 22 100 57 58 .290 .348 .457 *3
8 Rob Wilfong 1979 25 10 25 MIN 140 485 71 131 22 6 9 59 29 54 .313 .352 .458 *4/879
9 Bert Campaneris 1976 18 11 34 OAK 149 631 67 137 14 1 1 52 63 80 .256 .331 .291 *6
10 Brooks Robinson 1962 10 10 25 BAL 162 697 77 192 29 9 23 86 42 70 .303 .342 .486 *5/64
11 Johnny Temple 1959 11 13 31 CIN 149 696 102 186 35 6 8 67 72 40 .311 .380 .430 *4
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool UsedGenerated 8/23/2013.

That’s it -11 player seasons in the last 60 years. Relaxing it to find players with double-digit seasons of both, but in different years, still yields a remarkably small group.

Rk  Player SF Yrs From-To SH Yrs From-To
1 B.J. Surhoff 4 1989-1998 2 1988-1991
2 Brooks Robinson 3 1962-1969 2 1960-1962
3 Roberto Alomar 2 1996-1999 6 1988-2003
4 Omar Vizquel 2 1995-2002 14 1989-2007
5 Robin Yount 2 1982-1992 4 1975-1979
6 Gil Hodges 2 1954-1955 2 1949-1950
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool UsedGenerated 8/23/2013.

Above are the only players with 2 or more seasons with 10+ sacrifice flies, and also 2 or more seasons with 10+ sacrifice bunts.

So, it shouldn’t be surprising that we’ve never had a player lead his league in both categories in the same season. I did say, though, that there have been players to lead their league in both categories in different seasons. Here they are:

Rk  Player Lg SF Title Lg SH Title
1 Roberto Alomar AL 1999 NL 1989
2 Vic Power AL 1961 AL 1963
3 Frank Bolling AL 1958 NL 1963
4 Johnny Temple NL 1959 NL 1957, 1958
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool UsedGenerated 8/23/2013.

So, only Roberto Alomar has done this since the early 1960s. And, he did so in widely separated seasons: leading in sac bunts when younger and quicker; and in sac flies when older and slower. Which makes Cozart’s season all the more interesting.

SPECIAL EXTRA

HHS reader brp mentioned that Cozart leading in both categories could be related to splitting his playing time between different spots in the batting order. Here, then are the record SH totals by batting order position and era.

BOP 1916-1929 1930-1949 1950-1969  1970-1989 1990-2012
1st 21 Morrie Rath 1919 20 Eddie Stanky 1946 17 Johnny Temple 1958

17 Johnny Temple 1956

19 Bert Campaneris 1972 19 Juan Pierre 2011 
2nd 65 Ray Chapman 1917 36 Dick Bartell 1933 30 Roy McMillan 1954 34 Craig Reynolds 1979 39 Jay Bell 1990 
3rd 39 Eddie Collins 1923 22 Ival Goodman 1939 15 Dave Philley 1952

15 Willie Jones 1951

11 Tony Gwynn 1989 11 Roberto Alomar 2000 
4th 37 Stuffy McInnis 1923 27 Adam Comorosky 1930 11 Ron Fairly 1965 Butch Wynegar 1977

Steve Garvey 1976

Fred Lynn 1975

3 Brian McCann 2009

3 Norberto Martin 1996

3 Gary Gaetti 1995

3 Kent Hrbek 1993

3 Chris Sabo 1991 

5th 39 Stuffy McInnis 1920 18 Pinky Whitney 1932

18 Jimmie Foxx 1930

9 Ernie Banks 1968 Jim Morrison 1980 5 Juan Encarnacion 2003

5 Orlando Cabrera 2002

5 Bret Boone 2001

5 Jeff King 1992 

6th 30 Lu Blue 1925 19 Bing Miller 1930 11 Gil Hodges 1950 11 Larry Herndon 1978 5 Ronnie Belliard 2005

5 Shawon Dunston 1995

5 Jeff Kent 1993

5 Kevin Young 1993

5 Casey Candaele 1992 

7th 40 Everett Scott 1917 24 Marty Marion 1941 10 George Strickland 1955

10 Sam Dente 1950

12 Manny Trillo 1975 Kirt Manwaring 1991 
8th 21 Rube Lutzke 1927

21 Ray Schalk 1920

21 Billy Myers 1939 14 Hal Lanier 1968

14 Buddy Kerr 1950

22 Tim Foli 1982 14 Rey Ordonez 1998 
9th 20 Urban Shocker 1927

20 Urban Shocker 1926

17 Paul Derringer 1939 17 Phil Niekro 1968 21 Bob Meacham 1985

21 Bob Boone 1982

21 Mark Belanger 1975

20 Javier Vazquez 2009

20 Roy Oswalt 2006 

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool UsedGenerated 8/26/2013.

And, the same for sacrifice flies. Note that Bert Campaneris, Roberto Alomar and Shawon Dunston show up in both the Sacrifice Hit and Sacrifice Fly tables.

BOP 1954-1969 1970-1989 1990-2012
1st 12 Johnny Temple 1959 8 Lou Whitaker 1983

8 Don Kessinger 1975

12 Johnny Damon 2000
2nd 8 Al Dark 1956 10 Jim Gantner 1984

10 Bert Campaneris 1976

15 Mark Loretta 2004
3rd 11 Alex Johnson 1969 18 Andre Dawson 1983 13 Roberto Alomar 1999

13 Carlos Baerga 1993

13 Frank Thomas 1993

13 Joe Carter 1992

13 Kelly Gruber 1990

13 Will Clark 1990

4th 14 Ron Santo 1969 14 Dave Kingman 1984 16 Juan Gonzalez 2001
5th 10 Jackie Jensen 1959 10 Rico Petrocelli 1970 13 J.T. Snow 2000

13 Barry Bonds 1991

6th 10 Jim Piersall 1956 8 Jim Presley 1985

8 Ray Knight 1983

8 Garry Maddox 1981

8 Edgar Renteria 2004

8 Richard Hidalgo 2001

7th 6 Reno Bertoia 1958

6 Joe DeMaestri 1954

8 Rey Quinones 1989

8 Ray Knight 1986

8 Shawon Dunston 1991
8th 9 Dick Hall 1954 9 Dale Berra 1984 7 Mike Lamb 2008

7 Dan Wilson 2002

9th 4 Denny Lemaster 1964

4 Warren Spahn 1959

4 Bob Keegan 1954

9 Bucky Dent 1977 11 Kevin Elster 1996
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool UsedGenerated 8/26/2013.

 

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
no statistician but
no statistician but
11 years ago

Ray Chapman’s 1917 season was remarkable, not only for the 67 SHs but for the 7.8 WAR he tallied, trailing only a guy named Ty in the AL.

As Bill James points out in the NBJHA, Chapman was well on his way to a HOF level career when he was felled.

paget
paget
11 years ago

Extra amazing thing about Chapman’s year in 1917: following contemporary rules (that don’t count sacrifices as AB) he would have had a batting average of .343!

brp
brp
11 years ago

I would think the sacrifice flies is the hard part here. SFs require a guy to be on 3rd base (at least as they have been counted for most of history), whereas you can get a SH with runners on any base combination. Most of Cozart’s PAs have come in the #2 and #7 spot, and all his SFs and SHs from those areas. Leading the league in SH while batting 2nd does make sense according to the old-school managing style, and there’s nothing new about Dusty Baker. I mean, the man’s first name is Dusty. Four of the 9… Read more »

Jacob
Jacob
11 years ago

Nice article, Doug. Cozart clearly excels in the act of sacrifice; I’m almost certain he also displays a flair for the dramatic with chess.