20 Questions – Who Am I?

I have a player in mind. Your job is to guess who he is. To help you guess, you can ask me questions. But, only objective questions and only questions that can be answered Yes/No.

You have to get the answer within 20 questions to win. All questions, whether good or bad, count towards the 20 total. So, be careful to word your questions correctly.

Congratulations to bstar, who solved the quiz on the 10th question. The hints were a 10-year player who played entirely since 1961 and who ranked first (best) in one career statistical category and last (worst) in another, both among players who played only in 1961 or later. The answer is Greg Minton, who played from 1975 to 1990, and ranks first in HR/9 ratio and last in SO/BB ratio (both for min. 1000 IP) among pitchers who have played only since 1961.

Some examples of good questions:

  • Did this player ever lead his league in home runs in a season?
  • Did this player play primarily in the National League?

And, examples of bad questions:

  • Was this player a good hitter?
  • What was the principal team this player played on?

To get you started, I’ll give you a few hints. I am a player who:

  • played my entire career in the expansion era (1961 to present)
  • played for more than 10 years
  • ranks first (best) in a common career statistical category among all players who also played their entire careers since 1961
  • ranks last (worst) in another common career statistical category among all players who also played their entire careers since 1961

So, who am I?

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

73 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Doug, with trepidation, I’ll use up a question …. Am I a pitcher?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

I’ll spend one more question and then I’ll turn it over to better baseball minds than mine.

Did I ever throw a no-hitter?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

S**t, I mean, sugar. I thought I had a lead…. back to the drawing board.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago

Did I play over 50% of my career in the National League?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Doug, you know this is going to tantalize Internet baseball stat freaks all night long.

(Please, don’t count this as a question.) 🙂

Darien
12 years ago

I ask, also with trepidation: am I retired?

Darien
12 years ago

I ask, also with trepidation: am I retired?

I’m getting a ton of errors trying to post this; if it double-posts, I apologise. Please count it as only one question due to technical complications. Probably PEBKAC-related. 😀

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Yes, Doug, I was shut also…. Andy needs a more robust provider.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

…. oops, shut out ….

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

OK, guys, the next question has to be frickin’ good. Who wants to ask it?

The meter is running at 4 questions.

Now, Doug, no pressure, but you said “common” career stat.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

Aw, geez, cut me some slack…..

@tranquil_serene
@tranquil_serene
12 years ago

Is the statistic winning strikeouts and you are Nolan Ryan?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Tranquil… I asked if he had a no-hitter.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

Thanks, Doug, and by the way great blog. ~sucks up~

@tranquil_serene
@tranquil_serene
12 years ago

I missed/skipped the nono question. Sorry about that.
Were you predominantly a relief pitcher?
(and without burning it- lefty or righty need to be asked )

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Doug’s lips are sealed ….. until a real question is asked.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago

Were you a left-handed pitcher?

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago

Does your leading those two categories apply only to those who played entirely since 1961?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

Stop wasting questions, JA. 🙂

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

I respectfully disagree that my question was answered in the post. It was implied, but not stated definitively. For instance, if I said that Cy Young had the most wins of anyone who pitched solely in the dead-ball era, that would be a 100% true statement — but my specifying the time boundary would imply that someone else who pitched later had more wins, which of course is not so.

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

Doug, it seems to me that all you’ve done there is repeat what you said in the original post. It’s moot now, but to put my question another way: Is there anyone who pitched at least some of his career *before* 1961 who is better than the mystery man in either of the two referenced categories? For example, Goose Gossage leads in, say, relief wins since 1961. But he does not lead all-time. The time boundary specified in your initial statement implied that said pitcher was NOT the all-time leader. But I have seen people make subtly misleading statements in… Read more »

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

Doug @53, may I ask whatever brought Greg Minton to mind as a subject for you trivia quiz?

You were doing some obscure fiddling with the Play Index? 🙂

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

Oddly, I think it was at this same exact time that I revisited Moon Man’s player page also.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

Perranoski is second behind Minton in HR/9 since ’61. Here’s the only three under 0.40 HR/9:

1. Greg Minton 0.34
2. Ron Perranoski 0.38
3. Kent Tekulve 0.39

Perranoski was a little before my time. Was Ron a submariner?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Darn, the twittosphere is lighting up over this one ……..

bstar
bstar
12 years ago

Does anyone besides Doug know what the qualification is as far as IP for relievers? I think I’ve got a really good guess

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

bstar, what do you mean by “qualification”? Please elaborate.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

How many IP to qualify as a leader in a rate category? Is it 1000 IP?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

bstar, I respect your knowledge…. phrase your guess as a definitive question.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago

I think I’ve got this: Is it Greg Minton, the leader in HR/9 but worst in SO/BB since 1961?

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

Thanks. I knew Minton had the HR/9 title; finding what he was worst at took a little longer.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

bstar, you rock!! ~bows to bstar~

How did you know it was a reliever…. oh, you’re a Braves fan. 🙂

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

Somebody asked about the reliever part earlier, Neil.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

Darn, got all excited and missed that answer, bstar.

Your “real” life exists in the baseball blogosphere! 🙂 Well done!

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

Thanks, Neil. Minton also holds the post-deadball record for consecutive IP without allowing a HR. He went over 3 full seasons(269.1 IP) before giving up a dinger to John Stearns on May 2, 1982.

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

The HR by Stearns that ended Minton’s streak: (a) was one of four he hit that year in 392 PAs; (b) was his only career hit off Minton in 8 PAs; and (c) came with 2 outs in an inning prolonged by an E6 (em>thanks again, Johnny Disaster). The floodgates thus opened, Minton gave up 2 more HRs in his next 4 games — a 2-out walk-off by Rusty Staub, and a go-ahead 2-run shot by Gary Matthews. And yet … Despite giving up 5 HRs, ’82 was by far Minton’s most valuable season — in fact, it’s #8 all-time… Read more »

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

According to Wikipedia, Minton suffered a devastating leg injury in ’79 and was forced to alter his high-leg-kick delivery. After that, batters had a lot of trouble getting any lift on his sinker.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

Doug, post a spoiler alert in the header to this blog and let people scroll through the answers for themselves.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago

John and bstar, do either of you have a chat sidebar on your screens?

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Neil L.

Neil, Andy disabled it as it was causing problems with the site.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

Thanks, for the info. No real-time chat. I missed the notification about the disablement.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

Hey Doug, do you think it would have been better if I would have posted the answer in a remote place(like the Chat Room available on the toolbar) and had you check to see if I was right? That way, everyone else could have continued to guess. I feel like I brought the party to a crashing halt in a way.

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

Stop basking in the afterglow of your triumph, bstar.

Hey Doug, without chat, this blog might catch up to Graham’s
for most comments.

Bstar, this site gets addictive, no?

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

It was a serious question. But yeah, I’m a baskin’!

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

Had you done that, b, how could we be appropriately impressed? 🙂

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

Now, if you solve the next few quizzes in similar abrupt fashion, we may have to figure out some sort of Harrison Bergeron handicaps for you. 🙂

(I’m going for the record in consecutive smiley comments, by the way.)

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

Then maybe I did you a favor! 🙂

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

I miss me some chat right now. They’re restarting the Braves-Rockies game. If the Braves hold on(it’s 12-9 right now), this will be the third straight game Atlanta has overcome a 5+ run deficit to win the game. No idea if this is searchable on the P-I, but that’s got to be close to a record.

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  bstar

How ’bout those Bugs Bunny breaking balls from Livan?

Neil L.
Neil L.
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

JA, it wass gratifying to see the Mets’ pen hold up today.

bstar
bstar
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

Livan gets his first save ever in his 495th career game. Disregard comment #59, the Braves have overcome a 5+ run deficit to win 3 of the last 4 games, not 3 straight.