The greatest Detroit Tiger: Brandon Inge ?!?!?!?!?

Brandon Inge / PRESSWIRE

Brandon Inge was released by the Tigers and is poised to join the Oakland Athletics. For a while, it looked as if Inge would spend his entire major-league career with the Tigers. At the moment, before he plays a game with another team, you might be surprised to find out where he ranks among players who played for only the Tigers.

Let’s start with career homers. A lot o you can probably guess right off the top of your head that among players who played for only the Tigers, Al Kaline ranks #1 in homers with 399. Next up is Lou Whitaker at 244, followed by Bill Freehan at 200. Then come three closely clustered guys: Bobby Higginson (187), Alan Trammell (185), and Charlie Gehringer (184). Inge is next at #7 with 140 homers.

The RBI looks like this: #1 Kaline 1583, #2 Gehringer 1427, #3 Whitaker 1084, #4 Trammell 1003, #5 Freehan 758, #6 Higginson 709, #7 Inge 589.

Inge also had great flexibility. He played more than 300 games at both catcher and 3B for the Tigers. Only one other player had as many as 80 games at each of those 2 positions, and that was Marty Castillo with 120 games at 3B and 80 at C.

In fact, since 1901, only 3 players in all of baseball have played at least 300 games at both C and 3B, and they are Inge, Joe Torre, and B.J. Surhoff.

And how about this…since 1901, the only guys to play at least 10 games at C, 3B, LF, and CF:

Rk From To Age G PA HR RBI BA OBP SLG OPS Pos Tm
1 Wally Schang 1913 1931 23-41 1841 6427 59 710 .284 .393 .401 .794 *2/78596 BOS-NYY-SLB-PHA-DET
2 Randy Moore 1927 1937 21-31 751 2450 27 308 .278 .326 .378 .705 9/357824 CHW-BSN-BRO-TOT
3 Gary Kolb 1960 1969 20-29 293 501 6 29 .209 .281 .296 .577 /9728543 STL-MLN-TOT-PIT
4 Brandon Inge 2001 2012 24-35 1408 5196 140 589 .234 .304 .387 .691 *52/874D9 DET
5 Roger Bresnahan 1901 1915 22-36 1438 5355 26 527 .279 .386 .377 .764 *28/5934761 BLA-TOT-NYG-STL-CHC
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 4/30/2012.

The interesting part is the last column…franchises played for. These other guys were largely utility types who caught on with different teams and stuck around for a while. Not Inge…he brought flexibility to the Tigers and stayed there for 12 years.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

17 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
topper009
topper009
12 years ago

“These other guys were largely utility types who caught on with different teams and stuck around for a while”

Maybe half of them, Roger Bresnahan is in the HOF and Wally Schang was better than a few of the other catchers who are enshrined.

John Autin
Editor
12 years ago

Ah, geez, did you have to bring up Marty Castillo? — the man who moved Sparky to such unwarranted devotion that he buried HoJo in the ’84 postseason (1 PA after being the regular at 3B), then dealt him to the Mets that winter. Now that I’ve read (and reread and reread) JoePos’s fabulous The Machine, with the saga of how Sparky dumped the good-field, no-hit 3B John Vuckovich in favor of the good-hit, no-field Pete Rose, it’s all the more puzzling why Sparky made the opposite move in the ’84 postseason. I think sometimes the manager of a juggernaut… Read more »

Doug
Doug
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

If I was a Tiger fan, I wouldn’t be too upset about the 1984 postseason.

Max
Max
12 years ago
Reply to  John Autin

Nor would I be too upset at Hojo’s overall postseason stats with the Mets. Plus, Walt Terrell was a pretty good pitch for you.

birtelcom
Editor
12 years ago

Inge led all AL third basemen in baseball-reference’s WAR in 2006. Fangraphs’ WAR has him behind several guys that season by a fraction of win.

Doug
Editor
12 years ago

Inge has the 15th lowest career OPS+ among all player with 3000 PAs who played at least half their games at 3B.

He joins a long list of other Tigers on that list of light-hitting third basemen, including Bob Jones (75 OPS+), Aurelio Rodriguez (76), Ossie Vitt (80), Marv Owen (80), Tom Brookens (83), George Moriarty (84), Don Wert (87) and Bill Coughlin (87).

So, 9 of the 25 lightest hitting 3rd baseman ever played a majority of their careers with the Tigers.

Lawrence Azrin
Lawrence Azrin
12 years ago
Reply to  Doug

As usual, Bill James had a short article on this subject (light-hitting third basemen on the Tigers) somewhere in his NBJHA, I can’t remember under what player. Aurelio Rodriguez was a brilliant defensive third baseman(a B-R Rfield of +88 confirms this), I understand why he had a long career, but for the rest, you gotta wonder how they lasted so long. I thought Ty Cobb as a manager made his players better hitters, but Bob Jones lasted five years under Cobb with an OPS+ no better than 87% (he did hit .303 his first year in 1921). Maybe it’s just… Read more »

Hartvig
Hartvig
12 years ago
Reply to  Lawrence Azrin

Third base is kind of a black hole in Tigers history. At every other position except left field they have at least 1 player who could be argued to be among the 10 greatest ever. Only 4 players I can think of gave Detroit more than a season or 2 of decent offensive production: Pinky Higgins, George Kell, Ray Boone and Travis Fryman and of those 4, Higgins & Fryman were only about league average with the bat in their hands and Kell & Boone had 9 seasons between them playing for the Tigers that I would call very good… Read more »

birtelcom
Editor
12 years ago
Reply to  Hartvig

I asked the Play Index for the number of players who played at least 500 games at third base, and accumulated at least 20 WAR, for each franchise since 1901. The Tigers were the only one of the 16 franchises that date back to 1901, to have had only two such guys: Travis Fryman and George Kell. All the other 15 pre-expansion franchises had at least three such guys, plus the expansion-era Brewers and Mets franchises each have had three such guys and the expansion era Rangers and Angels franchises match the Tigers’ total of two. The Giants and Twins… Read more »

KalineCountry
12 years ago

Hartvig, You are right regarding 3B in Tigers history. Veach and Horton in Leftfield aren’t top 10 all time. Many of us started calling Inge – Cringe the last couple of years, with his mediocre/poor hitting. iirc, Inge is second in Tigers history to Kaline in dWAR. Good guy, 3/4 fairly good years.
Not sure if you are a Tigers fan, but love the pic of Don Mossi.

Hartvig
Hartvig
12 years ago
Reply to  KalineCountry

I am a Tiger fan but the Mossi pick is mostly coincidental- I started following baseball in the early ’60’s but being in North Dakota my first team was the dreaded Yankees (hey, I was about 6 years old and they were winning)- I kind of switched over to the Tigers in the mid-60’s and have stuck with them ever since except for a brief flirtation with the Brewers when I lived in Green Bay for a couple of years. My memories of Mossi are from opening packs of baseball cards as a kid. Inge has been something of a… Read more »

Steven
Steven
12 years ago
Reply to  KalineCountry

Everytime I look at a keyboard on a typewriter or computer, there he is. First four letters, next to Q. Don Wert, Tiger third baseman of the mid-to-late sixties.

Don Malcolm
12 years ago
Reply to  Steven

Steven,

It’s an unfounded rumor that Wert’s name was not shortened from Wertelowski, but from Qwerty…!

Don Wert was on the All-Star team in ’68: the year he hit .200. Inserted into the game as a replacement for Brook Robinson, he doubled off Tom Seaver in his only ASG plate appearance…

Voomo Zanzibar
Voomo Zanzibar
12 years ago

Ty Cobb?
1805 Tiger Ribbys

Tbone
Tbone
12 years ago

Brandon Inge = career 84 OPS+ !?! I was surprised it was this low actually. I expected maybe 98-102.

John Sharp
12 years ago

In career Tigers HR you left off Hank Greenberg, who walloped 306 HRS for the Tigers.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/g/greenha01.shtml

Zoila
10 years ago

Everyone loves what you guys are usually up too.
This type of clever work and coverage! Keep up the amazing works guys I’ve added you guys to my personal blogroll.