It has been widely noted that some of the trends associated with the immediate post-baseball-strike period (1995 through the early years of the 21st century) have abated over the last few seasons. Home runs and run scoring are both down from their peak, as are walks and hits.
Average home runs per team per game 2000: 1.17
Average home runs per team per game 2011: 0.94
Average runs per team per game 2000: 5.14
Average runs per team per game 2011: 4.28
Average hits per team per game 2000: 9.31
Average hits per team per game 2011: 8.70
Average walks per team per game 2000: 3.75
Average walks per team per game 2011: 3.09
But one stat that was also historically high in the heavy run-scoring period that peaked around 10 years ago has continued to climb ever higher. That’s strikeouts. More details after the jump.
Even though hits, homers, runs and walks were occurring at near all-time highs in the majors in the late 90s-early 2000s, strikeouts were also very high. The full season average for strikeouts per team per game went over 6.5 for the first time in major league history in 1997. Over the four-year period 1998-2001, the overall Ks per game average across the majors continued to be high, averaging 6.52 over that four-year period. But since then, K’s have not ebbed in parallel with hits, walks, runs and homers. The all-time record for the highest MLB-wide strikeout per game rate has been broken every year for the last four years in a row. The four highest MLB-wide averages for a season in history:
2008: 6.77
2009: 6.91
2010: 7.06
2011: 7.10
At this point it is routine, rather than a surprise, when each new season brings another all-time record for most strikeouts across the majors. To put that 7.10 Ks per game number for 2011 in perspective, note that the overall average for all regular season games across the entire hundred seasons from 1900 through 1999 was 4.35 Ks per game.
Indeed, the general upward trend in strikeouts has been going on more or less steadily in MLB for 90 years. Every decade since the 1920s, except for the 1970s (when the mounds were lowered and the AL replaced flailing pitchers with the DH) has seen more Ks per game in the majors than the decade before:
Average Strikeouts Per Team Per Game, MLB Regular Season
1920-1929: 2.81
1930-1939: 3.32
1940-1949: 3.55
1950-1959: 4.40
1960-1969: 5.70
1970-1979: 5.15
1980-1989: 5.34
1990-1999: 6.14
2000-2009: 6.56
2010-2011: 7.08
In moderation, strikeouts can be a fun part of the game for fans. But I wonder whether the ever-lengthening parade of Ks is becoming a bit much. With home runs declining, maybe hitters should be adjusting strategies to make more contact and get the ball in play. The sport is baseball after all, not “swingball”, “strikeball” or “missball”. More action on the field of play, more running around on the bases, more testing of defensive prowess, and a bit less of the chess match between pitcher and hitter (as compelling as that can be), might be desirable from the spectator’s point of view.